Single Page Application vs Multi Page Application

The path to creating a successful web application requires careful consideration of the technology stack and architecture that we choose. In web development, an age-old debate revolves around single-page applications (SPAs) versus multi-page applications (MPAs). With so many opinions, it can be tricky to figure out what’s best for your web development.

We will take a look at what SPAs and MPAs are, their advantages and disadvantages, and their key attributes. We will also see real-world scenarios where SPAs or MPAs excel, ensuring that we are armed with the knowledge needed to choose between SPA and MPA.

Single Page Applications (SPA) vs. Multi-Page Applications (MPA) – A Comprehensive Comparison

The two popular approaches that stand out in web application development are Single Page Applications (SPA) and Multi-Page Applications (MPA). Both have their strengths and weaknesses and understanding the differences between them can help us make informed choices.

A single-page application (SPA) is a modern way to build apps, like the ones Google, Facebook, Twitter, and others use. SPAs are like apps that run in our web browser, and they don’t need to reload the whole page when we use them.

A multiple-page application (MPA) is a more traditional approach to app development. With MPAs, every time we want to see something new, the whole web page has to reload. E-commerce companies with lots of products often prefer this approach.

We will explore the differences like speed, coupling, search engine optimization (SEO), user experience, security, development process, and JavaScript dependency in greater detail.

What is a Single Page Application (SPA)?

A single-page application is a web app that operates within a web browser without the need for page reloading while in use.

How Does a Single-Page Application Work?

SPAs deliver an exceptional user experience by giving us a smooth, “natural” browsing environment without any interruptions. They consist of a single webpage that loads all content through JavaScript, depending heavily on advanced frameworks like AngularJS, Ember.js, Meteor.js, and Knockout.js. SPAs independently fetch markup and data, rendering pages directly in the browser.

These sites maintain users within a single, user-friendly web space, presenting content straightforwardly and efficiently, and ensuring a comfortable and cohesive experience.

In 2022 according to Statista, JavaScript and HTML/CSS stood out as the prevailing programming languages in the global software developer community. Approximately 63.6 percent of respondents reported using JavaScript, while roughly 53 percent utilized HTML/CSS.

Examples of Single-Page Applications

Every day thousands of users use Single-Page Applications without even realizing it. Some of the popular examples include Facebook, Twitter, Gmail, Google Maps, and Google Drive. These applications use JavaScript to load the content and update and change it as one navigates.

Pros and Cons of Single-Page Applications

Pros of Single Page Application

Single Page Applications come with several advantages that make them a popular choice for web development:

Performance: SPAs tend to be faster after the initial page load. This is because HTML, CSS, and scripts are loaded just once, and only data is transmitted between the server and the user.
Improved User Experience: SPAs offer a better user experience by providing faster responses, mobile-friendly interfaces, effortless interaction, and a linear content flow.
Connectivity: SPAs can work offline to some extent since most of the content is available after the initial load. This makes them accessible even with a poor or no internet connection.
Development Speed: Developers find SPAs developer-friendly. They require testing fewer elements, allow code reuse, and enable easy network operations monitoring.

Cons of Single Page Application

However, SPAs also have some drawbacks:

Initial Loading Time: SPAs may load many scripts at once, even if users don’t need all of them. This can slow down the initial loading of the first page.
SEO Limitations: SPAs can pose challenges for search engine optimization (SEO) since search engines don’t interpret JavaScript well. Server-side rendering with frameworks like NextJS or GatsbyJS can help address this issue.

Single-page applications offer speed, user-friendliness, offline capabilities, and development efficiency but come with trade-offs like initial loading time and SEO limitations.

Sign up with ellow, and access 25,000+ pre-vetted developer profiles, and start building your development team in 48 hours.

What is a Multi-Page Application (MPA)?

A Multi-Page Application, or MPA, is a type of website or web application where each page is separately created and sent to our web browser by a server.

Unlike Single Page Applications (SPAs), which build pages in our browser using JavaScript, MPAs depend on the server to generate and refresh pages. This means that every time a user interacts with an MPA, for example, clicking a link or submitting a form, the server sends a new page to the browser.

How Does a Multi-Page Application Work?

In a Multi-Page Application, when there is an action like clicking on a link or submitting a form, the server creates a new page with the updated content and sends it to our browser. This constant communication with the server is necessary to ensure that we see the most up-to-date information on each page.

Examples of Multi-Page Applications

Multi-page applications are commonly used for e-commerce websites, including online marketplaces and product catalogs. When a website or app needs to make significant changes as you move from one page to another, developers often opt for the MPA approach. So, when shopping for Christmas gifts on Amazon or searching for a vintage record player on eBay, we are using an MPA.

Pros and Cons of Multi-Page Applications

Now, let’s explore the advantages and disadvantages of Multi-Page Applications.

Pros of Multi-Page Application

SEO Optimization is Possible: One major advantage of MPAs is their SEO-friendliness. Each page in an MPA has its unique URL, allowing developers to optimize them with meta tags and updated content. If attracting high website traffic and search engine optimization are essential for the business, MPAs are a great choice.
Ease of Scaling: MPAs provide a flexible canvas for developers. One can add as many pages as needed to accommodate their content and features. However, it is important to note that as the number of pages increases, performance might decrease, so careful planning is required.
Analytic Capabilities: Compared to SPAs, MPAs offer extensive opportunities for data analysis, such as tracking the number of visitors, their session durations, and target audience behavior. Analytics tools often perform better when the server manages the pages, rather than relying on the browser. While achieving these insights may require additional effort, MPAs have the upper hand in this aspect.

Cons of Multi-Page Application

Performance Speed: In MPAs, every time a page is refreshed or navigates to a new one, the browser has to reload and display all the content from scratch. This can lead to slower performance, especially on slower internet connections.
Cost: Unlike SPAs, which rely on client-side resources like memory and processors, MPAs require server resources. This means additional costs for hosting and maintaining servers, making them less cost-effective for some projects.

Multi-page applications offer benefits like SEO optimization, scalability, and robust analytic capabilities. However, they come with drawbacks such as potential performance issues and increased hosting costs.

Factors to Consider when choosing one of them

When choosing between Single-Page Applications (SPA) and Multi-Page Applications (MPA) for a website or app creation, there are several key factors. Let us explore these factors to help us make a decision.

Speed

Users have little patience for waiting in today’s digital fast paced world while browsing, and Single Page Applications (SPAs) offer a notable advantage in this regard.. They load quickly because they fetch most of the app resources just once. This means when a user requests new data, the entire page doesn’t reload.

On the other hand, MPAs tend to be slower. Why? Because every time you want to see something new or move to a different part of the website, the browser reloads the whole page from scratch. The optimal loading time for a website is 0.4 seconds, and if a website is heavy on images, choosing an SPA might be a better choice for speed.

Coupling

SPA and MPA have different approaches to coupling. SPAs are strongly decoupled, which means the front-end and back-end are separate entities. In SPAs, the front end uses APIs developed by server-side developers to read and display data. In contrast, MPAs are more interdependent, with both front-end and back-end often housed under one project.

Search Engine Optimization (SEO)

SEO is crucial for visibility on the web and search engines. Unfortunately, SPAs have a weakness in this area. Most single-page applications run on JavaScript, which many search engines don’t fully support. Search engines typically index web pages by “crawling” or “spidering” through HTML files, making static HTML pages easier to rank.

MPAs, however, have an advantage when it comes to SEO. Each page can be optimized for different keywords, and meta tags can be added to every page, which positively impacts rankings on search engines like Google.

User Experience

User experience is a top priority nowadays. SPAs excel in mobile-friendliness, which is essential as a significant amount of traffic comes from mobile devices. The mobile experience is so critical that even Google prioritizes it over the desktop experience. The frameworks used in SPA development enable the creation of mobile apps.

MPAs, on the other hand, shine in information architecture. You can create numerous pages and include as much information as needed without limitations. Clear navigation in MPAs makes it easy for users to find their way around, enhancing their overall experience.

Security

Bigger websites often mean more security challenges, especially for multi-page applications. If an MPA is opted, there is a need to secure each web page individually. In SPAs, securing data endpoints is crucial but slightly different. SPAs are more vulnerable to hacker attacks because they rely on JavaScript, which doesn’t perform code compilation, making it susceptible to malware.

Development Process

SPA’s reusable backend code is a significant advantage. Reusing code means less work, and the same code can be used for both the web and mobile apps. This is important because most users access applications and websites on their mobile devices.

There is a clear separation between front-end and back-end in SPAs, both parts can be developed simultaneously, speeding up the overall development process. In contrast, MPAs often require coding the server side from scratch, which can extend the development timeline.

JavaScript Dependency

SPAs heavily rely on JavaScript, which can present challenges. While more search engines are starting to support JavaScript, the level of support varies depending on the JavaScript framework used. If a user disables JavaScript in their browser, it can lead to functionality issues, higher bounce rates, and lower conversion rates. JavaScript dependency also contributes to SEO and security concerns. But MPAs can be built without any JavaScript dependency.

In the present day, nearly every type of device, including Windows, Linux, macOS, Android, iOS, and smart TVs, extensively relies on the most widely adopted JavaScript frameworks. As of 2022 according to Radixweb, within the 1.8 billion websites across the globe, an astounding 98% employ JavaScript as their preferred client-side programming language, underscoring its remarkable surge in popularity.

Key Takeaways

When deciding between a Single Page Application (SPA) and a Multi Page Application (MPA), there are some key considerations to consider.

Business Size and Complexity: If the business is large with numerous products, services, and features, an MPA with multiple items may be the way to go. It helps organize and showcase the offerings effectively.
Use Case: For SaaS platforms and social networking sites where SEO is not a top priority, SPAs work well due to their seamless user experience. SPAs load content dynamically without full-page refreshes.
Future Mobile Apps: To expand into mobile apps later, starting with a SPA is smart. SPAs can easily adapt to mobile interfaces, saving development time and effort.
E-commerce and Catalogs: MPAs suit online stores, marketplaces, and catalog-style websites. They facilitate better navigation and product categorization.

When it comes to deciding between single-page apps (SPAs) and multi-page apps (MPAs) for web development, it’s important to take a thorough approach. This means we need to consider two key factors: the advantages and drawbacks of each architecture and the specific needs of our web application.

To make the right choice, it’s often valuable to consult with experts and collaborate with a highly skilled software development team who can provide valuable insights and guidance and Ellow’s global talent pool of 25,000+ vetted developers will give you access to a diverse range of skills and expertise to meet your specific project needs and drive innovation in your organization.

Sign up with ellow, and access 25,000+ pre-vetted developer profiles, and start building your development team in 48 hours.

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the difference between single-page and multi-page apps?

A single-page app loads everything we need from the server once and doesn’t reload the page with each click. Multi-page apps, on the other hand, fetch a new page from the server for each change, causing full-page reloads and resource downloads.

When should I use a multi-page app?

Multi-page apps are preferable for two reasons: They’re more SEO-friendly than single-page apps, and they tend to be more scalable.

What's the main benefit of a single-page application?

Single-page apps minimize data transfer between the server and client, resulting in faster load times. Additionally, they decouple server-side code from the UI for efficient development.

Suvankar Das

He is a growth expert at Ellow, specializing in tech and recruitment. An avid reader and ambitious traveler, he curates stories and finds wonder in the unchartered territories of the unknown. With a passion for nature and creating peaceful environments, Suvankar brings a unique perspective to his work.